Petrol, manual, around 10 lakh

Six cars, one budget. Which one actually fits?

Swift, Exter, Nexon, Brezza, Venue and Sonet, compared on what you get per rupee and what you give up at each price. Move the budget, pick what matters, and the shortlist updates. Long-term service is weighted heavily: this is a ten-year decision.

Prices are ex-showroom, October 2026. Maharashtra on-road is roughly 17% higher.
Engines compared are the petrol manuals only.
Mileage is the ARAI claim; expect 20 to 25% less in Mumbai traffic.

The verdict

10 lakh on-road, firm

Swift ZXi+. The only car that is fully loaded at this price, and the cheapest to run. Take the Exter SX(O) instead if a sunroof and high seating matter more than how it drives.

Can stretch to 10.7 lakh on-road

Brezza VXi Turbo. 5-star safety, 6-speed, 20 kmpl, and Maruti's service network behind it. Take the 1.5 VXi if he wants the proven engine over the new turbo.

11 lakh on-road and above

Venue HX5 becomes worth it here: the most premium cabin and best build quality of the six, widest rear seat, newest design, Hyundai after-sales. Two catches: no spare wheel (repair kit only) and manual AC at this trim. Below this the Brezza does the same job for a lakh less.

Who looks after the car for the next decade

Service network, parts cost and dealer consistency matter more over ten years than any single feature. This is how the four brands stack up.

Maruti SuzukiLargest network in India by a wide margin, cheapest parts and labour, best resale. The safe default for a long ownership.
HyundaiSecond-largest network, consistently well-rated dealers, strong parts availability. Close to Maruti on peace of mind, a touch dearer per service.
KiaShares Hyundai parts and processes but far fewer touchpoints, especially outside metros. Fine if a good dealer is nearby, a gamble if not.
TataService is the recurring complaint from Nexon owners: slow turnaround, parts delays, uneven dealer quality, and electrical and infotainment niggles that take repeat visits to fix. The product has improved, the ownership experience has not kept up.

What does the budget buy?

Each row shows every petrol manual variant. Green fits the budget, the dark chip is the best variant you can afford, struck-out ones are above it.

₹10.0lakh
₹7 LOn-road estimate for Maharashtra, about 17% over ex-showroom₹13 L
FitsBest you can affordOver budget
Festive offers of ₹25k to ₹60k typically apply right now (Swift, Brezza 1.5 and Nexon especially; the new Brezza turbo usually has none). A variant one step above the line may still fit the budget, so ask the dealer for the final on-road figure before ruling it out.

Rank by what matters to you

Select one or more. The ranking weights those traits double.

Hardware, side by side

Swipe sideways to see all six. The first column stays put.

Features at the variant you'd actually buy

Not top trims, the recommended ones. Green is a clear win, red is a gap you will notice daily. The last row says what the next step up costs and adds.

Swipe sideways to see all six. The first column stays put.

Each car, honestly

In order of recommendation. The variant named is the one worth buying: the first trim where the car stops feeling like a fleet spec.